The debate between Border Collies and Pembroke Welsh Corgis has been going on for years. While both breeds are incredibly smart, loyal, and loving pets, each breed has its own unique traits and characteristics.
The Border Collie comes from a long line of sheep-herding dogs in Scotland, while the Pembroke Welsh Corgi is originally bred to herd livestock in Wales. Both breeds have been used as working dogs but excel at very different jobs.
Key Characteristics of Pembroke Welsh Corgi vs Border Collie
Pembroke Welsh Corgis and Border Collies are two popular breeds of herding dogs. They have some similarities but also clear differences that make them unique.
The Border Collie is an excellent herder with an incredible amount of energy, while the Corgi has a calm demeanor with a high level of intelligence that makes them perfect for obedience training or agility courses.
| Dog breed | Border Collie | Pembroke Welsh Corgi |
| Country of Origin | Scotland | Pembrokeshire, Wales |
| Origin year | 1860 AD | 1200 AD |
| Breed type | Pure breed | Pure breed |
| Lifespan | 12-15 years | 12-14 years |
| Coat | Smooth or rough double coat | Medium length, thick, weather-resist double coat |
| Height | 18-22 inch | 10-12 inch |
| Weight | 27-45 lb | 20-30 lb |
History of Pembroke Welsh Corgi vs Border Collie
The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is considered has been around for centuries. It is believed to have descended from the Vallhund of Sweden. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi was first recognized by The Kennel Club in 1925 and has since become a popular companion dog.
Its history is deeply rooted in the rural farms of Wales, where farmers used it to herd sheep, cows, and other livestock. Today, this loyal and friendly breed makes a wonderful family pet with intelligence, loyalty, and a good-natured temperament.
Border Collies were shipped from British ports to ranches and sheep farms worldwide. Obedience exhibitors in the United States were the first to notice the incredibly intelligent and hardworking dogs that had been brought to the country for this specific purpose.
Appearance of Corgi and Border Collie
Pembroke Welsh Corgis are medium-sized herding dogs. They typically have a shorter coat than other herding breeds and may not have much of a tail. Their skull is broad and flat and has a slightly rounded ear structure. The most distinguished feature of this breed is its double coat which comes in various color combinations such as red, sable, fawn, brindle, and black-and-tan.
The Border Collie is a medium-sized, athletic, and well-built dog breed. Their body shape is long and lean, their head is slightly rounded with a broad muzzle, their eyes are bright and alert, and their ears are erect and pointed. Their coat may be short or long, but it is usually thick and has a waterproof undercoat that helps protect them from the elements. The Border Collie’s tail typically curves towards its back.
Size of Border Collie vs Pembroke Welsh Corgi
Both breeds are quite different in size. A Border Collie stands 19.5 to 20.5 inches tall and weighs 34.5 to 37.5 pounds on average. A Pembroke Welsh Corgi, on the other hand, is typically 10.5 to 11 inches tall and weighs 26 to 27.5 pounds.
Coats & Colors
Border Collies are typically black and white, with a moderately long and smooth coat. On the other hand, Pembroke Welsh Corgi’s coats can be shortish and dense. They have short hair but still require frequent brushing to prevent matting.
Personality & Temperament of Border Collie vs Corgi
Both breeds are loyal, affectionate, energetic, and willing to please. However, there is a distinct difference in their personalities and temperaments. Border Collies tend to be stubborn. On the other hand, Corgis have a calmer demeanor, which makes them excellent lapdogs who love to snuggle up with their owners for comfort and do not like being alone.
Family and Pembroke Welsh Corgi vs Border Collie
Family-Friendly Pembroke Welsh Corgi: With a great deal of intelligence and care, the Pembroke Welsh Corgis make excellent family pets. They make good companions for children, as they’re gentle, trainable, and intelligent enough to keep up with many children’s playful games. They also have a sweet temperament, making them ideal for first-time pet owners.
Border Collie: As a herding breed, the Border Collie has been bred for high intelligence and trainability, as well as being active and eager to please their owners. They are also known for being one of the most intelligent breeds in history. Because of their high intelligence and training ability, they make ideal family pets, as they are intelligent enough to understand commands and have a natural propensity to herd.
Kids with Corgi vs Border Collie
Both of these breeds are good for children.
Corgis are small, compact, low-energy dogs. They can be a good choice for households with small children because they are less likely to knock kids over or trip them accidentally while playing.
On the other hand, Border collies are active and energetic dogs. Border collies would be a good choice for households with children who enjoy playing fetch and running outside. They are also less likely to knock kids over because they have longer legs than corgis.
Other People
When it comes to interacting with strangers or other people, both these breeds have unique personalities. While Corgis are known for being friendly and outgoing, Border Collies tend to be more independent and cautious around strangers. Knowing how your pet responds to things like this is needed to ensure that you can provide them with a safe environment when interacting with others.
Dogs & Other Animals
Corgis and Border Collies are often confused with each other because they are both members of the herding group. Within the Border Collie breed, their instincts and intelligence towards prey drive them to move in circles around their prey. This is why they are so prone to chasing small animals like cats.
Corgis are not bred with such specific behaviors towards small animals, so even if one does decide to chase after something smaller than themselves, it’s more likely that it will be done for fun and exploration purposes rather than out of a need for instinctual hunting behavior.
Behaviour Issues
Border Collie Behavior Issues: The Border Collie is a high-energy dog that needs lots of mental and physical stimulation. They should be given plenty of opportunities for agility exercises, regular games of catch, and other activities that require them to use their brains and bodies. The Border Collie will often start behaving badly if these needs are unmet.
Corgi Behavior Issues: The Corgi is a playful dog that adores human interaction. They will want you to play with them constantly, and they are so gentle and loving that they will rarely get bored or frustrated with the limits on their activity levels.
Training & Exercise of Pembroke Welsh Corgi vs Border Collie
Pembroke Welsh Corgi and Border Collie are both significant smart breeds of dogs, requiring different training and exercise.
Pembrokes need a relatively little exercise, around 20-40 minutes per day. Training Pembroke Welsh Corgi are highly-independent dogs and are known for being more passive. They require minimal training, such as teaching them to sit and stay, and they love to learn tricks. However, they can become bored more quickly than other breeds of dogs, so it is important to include lots of mental stimulation in their daily routine.
Border Collies typically require more than 40 minutes per day. They need to be walked and played with to stay healthy and happy. They should also have access to plenty of room for running, as they are known for being energetic and hyperactive dogs. Border Collies require lots of walking, playing with other dogs, digging holes in the yard to make tunnels and hiding places, and running on different surfaces daily so that they can maintain their health and happiness levels.
Taking Care & Maintenance of Corgi vs Border Collie
Pembroke Welsh Corgi and Border Collies Maintenance should cover the ears and be inspected regularly for wax buildup or infection, the nails should be clipped periodically, and the fur should be brushed daily. In addition, regular walking out is essential for both dogs’ well-being.
Grooming of Pembroke Welsh Corgi vs Border Collie
Grooming a pet is a very important part of ownership and must not be taken lightly. Pembroke Welsh Corgi and the Border Collie require the same amount of regular grooming.
However, Pembroke Welsh Corgi requires more frequent brushing than the Border Collie, as its coat is thicker and requires more maintenance. However, due to its longer fur, the Border Collie needs more frequent brushing than the Pembroke Welsh Corgi to help prevent matting.
Shedding
The Pembroke Welsh Corgi has soft fur that needs daily brushing but is short, silky, and considered moderate-shedding, while Border Collie sheds seasonally. It has a coat that can be dense with varying colors of fur depending on the color of the Border Collie’s coat. The Border Collies thick coat does not require much maintenance but has advantages like water repellency, wind resistance, and protection from parasites.
Health of Pembroke Welsh Corgi vs Border Collie
Both breeds are considered healthy dogs, but have different predispositions to certain health issues. Owners must understand the health needs of their chosen breed so that they can take steps to ensure their pet’s long-term health and well-being.
Life Span of Pembroke Welsh Corgi & Border Collie
Pembroke Welsh Corgi and Border Collie are quite different when it comes to their life span. Corgis have a life expectancy of 12-14 years, while Border Collies can live up to 12-15 years.
Diet & Nutrition
To ensure that your Pembroke Welsh Corgi and Border Collie are getting the best nutrition for their size, age, and lifestyle, it is important to know their diet and nutrition requirements. These two breeds have different dietary needs based on size and activity level.
If you’re going to feed commercial dog food to your Border Collie, make sure it’s from a reputable brand. Rashes and other skin problems can be avoided by including raw meat in his diet on a regular basis. You can also feed him rice, meat, and vegetables for variety and to ensure he gets enough essential nutrients. He requires clean, cold water at all times of the day and night.
Make sure the food you feed your Pembroke Welsh Corgi is free of artificial flavors, colors, and fillers. They require boiled and chopped chicken, brown rice or pasta, and cooked vegetables such as sweet potato, spinach, and carrots on occasion. Consider giving your pet a small amount of raw meat occasionally if you want him to have more energy, a shinier coat, fewer skin allergies, and less inflammation.
Health Issues
Both breeds are generally considered to be healthy. However, Pembroke Welsh Corgis and Border Collies are prone to genetic health conditions that need to be taken into consideration.
Pembroke Welsh Corgis are generally prone to Degenerative Myelopathy problems, while Border Collies are prone to developing Neuronal Ceroid Lipofuscinosis problems.
Cost of Pembroke Welsh Corgi vs Border Collie
The cost of a Pembroke Welsh Corgi versus a Border Collie depends on several factors, including the pup’s quality, age and health, and where you get them. Pembroke Welsh Corgis typically range from $1000 to $2000, while Border Collies can cost anywhere from $600 to $800. On average, Pembroke Welsh Corgis are more expensive than Border Collies due to their popularity as show dogs.
Puppies
The price for Pembroke Welsh Corgi puppies can vary depending on the breeder. On average, Pembroke Welsh Corgi puppies are priced at $1700, while Border Collie puppies cost $1,000.
Breeders & Centers
Breeders and centers play an important role in the well-being of dogs. They breed dogs with specific characteristics to meet the needs of different buyers. Dog breeding centers provide information and support for owners and potential owners by providing advice on diet, exercise, training, health care, grooming, and more.
Additionally, they provide a loving home to puppies who most need it. As such, these breeders and centers are essential to ensuring that all dogs live happy lives with their families.
Conclusion: Which Is Better, Pembroke Welsh Corgi or Border Collie?
Choosing between a Pembroke Welsh Corgi and a Border Collie can be difficult for many dog owners because both breeds have distinct personalities that make each unique and lovable. They both have something to offer potential owners, from their playful nature to intelligence level. Asking which is better is subjective, as it always depends on what you are looking for in a canine companion.
