Although there are certain similarities between these two breeds, The Stabyhoun and Border Collie have significant distinction. The former is classified under the Sporting Dogs group, while the latter belongs to the Herding Group. We’ll look at the comparison on this article to find the deal-breakers on choosing which one is for you.
Characteristics of a Friese Stabij and Border Collie
Border Collies are known for their playful and lively nature. They thrive in active families and their intelligence makes them great companions for children, as they seek attention and enjoy engaging in creative games and sports. Without proper engagement, they may become restless or exhibit unwanted behavior. Therefore, choosing the right pet is crucial for their overall well-being.
On the other hand, the Stabyhoun is a robust breed with a soft-mouthed pointing instinct. They possess a well-balanced physique and have tight skin. Their appearance is reminiscent of long-haired dogs, with feathery fur on their chest, legs, collar, and tail. Stabyhouns typically have long heads and bodies. While the breed is predominantly black and white, there are also endangered varieties in brown and orange-white colors.
|Height||49cm to 53cm||48cm to 56cm|
|Weight||47 kilogram to 50 kilogram||14 kilogram to 20 kilogram|
|Life Span||156 to 180 months (13 to 15 Years)||120 to 204 months (10 to 17 Years)|
|Size||Medium-sized dog||Medium-sized dog|
|Colors Available||Brown and white, black and white, orange and white (near extinct)||Blue merle, chocolate and white, white and black, liver and white|
|Temperament||Loving, attentive, active, approachable, free-spirited, clever, committed||Approachable, free-spirited, clever, zesty, caring, committed, gregarious, mischievous, guardian|
|Grooming||Moderate to difficult||Neutral|
|Other Names||Frisian Pointer, Friese stabij, Fryske Stabij, Stabij Beike Stabijhoun||Sheepdog, Scotch Sheep Dog|
History of Friese Stabij and Border Collie
The Border Collie, bred in Northumberland, originally specialized in herding cattle and gained fame for its ability to stare down lambs. The breed was officially designated as “Border Collie” in 1915, and sheepdog trials for this breed commenced in 1873. The term “Collie” is derived from a Scottish dialect and means sheepdog. Renowned for its intelligence and skill, the Border Collie is widely regarded as the premier sheep-herding dog. The American Kennel Club (AKC) recognized the Border Collie in October 1995.
Conversely, the Stabyhoun is an endangered breed with limited availability. While it is recognized by the Foundation Stock Services, it is not acknowledged by major kennel groups. Originating from the Dutch Frisian Forest in the early 19th century, it only gained recognition outside Friesland Forest in the 1960s and achieved international recognition in the 21st century. The term “Stabyhoun” translates to “stand by me dog” and is considered a Dutch national treasure. Globally, only a few thousand Stabyhouns remain, underscoring their rarity.
Appearance Comparison between Stabyhoun and Border Collie
The Border Collie is a medium-sized dog that can have either a smooth or rough coat, although the rough-coated variety is more common. Not only are they visually appealing, but Scotch sheep dogs are also known for their high intelligence. Border Collies have a lean physique with a slightly elongated body shape.
In contrast, the Stabyhoun possesses several unique physical characteristics. One of these is their smooth coat, which distinguishes them. The hair on their ears gradually becomes shorter from the top down, giving the ear the appearance of a mason’s trowel. Additionally, the legs and tail of the Stabyhoun display distinct hair patterns. The tail and the backs of the front and hind legs are bushy and lack feathers. Stabyhouns also have well-developed, relatively large feet and a broad brisket.
Border Collies are generally considered medium-sized dogs, typically ranging in height from 18 to 22 inches and weighing between 30 and 45 pounds. They have a well-balanced and agile physique, which allows them to excel in various physical activities and tasks. The height range of 18 to 22 inches puts them in the average height category for medium-sized dogs.
On the other hand, Stabyhouns are slightly taller than the average medium-sized dog. They typically stand between 19 and 20 inches tall, making them a bit shorter compared to Border Collies. This slight difference in height contributes to their unique appearance and may result in a more elongated body structure. In terms of weight, Stabyhouns usually weigh between 45 and 50 pounds, which places them within a similar weight range as Border Collies.
Coats & Colors
Border Collies exhibit various coat types that can be distinguished based on two characteristics: the type of hair or fur and the color. Among the different collie breeds, examples of coat characteristics include rough coat and silky coat. When it comes to color, Border Collies come in a wide range of options such as Lilac, Sable and Blue Merle, Tricolor, Brown, and White.
Conversely, the Stabyhoun boasts a distinctive long and sleek coat, often accompanied by distinct white patterns. This breed’s coat is commonly found in black, brown, and orange tones.
Personality & Temperament of a Stabyhoun and Border Collie
Border Collies, bred in the Scottish countryside, thrive in physically challenging environments and dislike being confined indoors. Their high activity levels require large fields or spacious backyards rather than apartments for them to live comfortably. Border Collies are known for their easily excitable nature, they often bark and can be boisterous. They also have a tendency to chase moving objects such as cars, motorcycles, and skateboards due to their innate instinct to respond quickly.
On the other hand, Stabyhouns are generally known for their calm, kind, and obedient nature. They share a strong bond with their family and strive to please their owners, although they may occasionally display some stubbornness. With a combination of soft-mouthed retrieving and pointing abilities, they make excellent hunting partners for ducks and upland birds.
Border Collies make great family pets, while they excel in canine sports due to their intelligence and trainability, mental and physical stimulation is vital. These dogs thrive when given outlets for their energy and intellectual engagement. Conversely, Stabyhouns are affectionate and eager to please. Their sharp minds and high energy levels contribute to their personality development. Regular work and purposeful activities provide the intellectual and physical stimulation they require to thrive as a family dog.
Some Border Collies may have challenges in interacting with young children due to their strong work ethics, lively personalities, and herding instincts. However, Border Collies can occasionally thrive in a family setting.
In contrast, the Stabyhoun hunting dog breed is known for its friendly and adaptable temperament towards humans, children, and other pets. Like any sporting breed, Stabyhouns require plenty of activity to maintain their happiness and serenity.
Border Collies, along with other herding breeds, have an inherent protective instinct, which can lead to wariness towards strangers. Early and consistent socialization is vital to prevent the development of shyness or aggression when encountering unfamiliar individuals.
Likewise, Stabyhouns also tend to display reserved behavior towards strangers. Early socialization is crucial to prevent fear or apprehension towards new people and situations. Proper socialization helps them feel more at ease and confident in different environments and people.
Dogs & Other Animals
As herding dogs, Border Collies often have the ability to coexist with other animals. However, the level of tolerance from each animal will determine whether they truly enjoy living with a Border Collie. Cats and Border Collies can live together, but the cats must be tolerant of the Border Collies’ herding instincts and constant checking behavior.
On the other hand, Stabyhouns are known for their kindness and warmth. They generally get along well with most dogs, familiar humans, and even cats and other small animals. Their friendly nature allows for peaceful interactions with a variety of species.
Without proper guidance or regular mental stimulation, Border Collies may exhibit undesirable behaviors such as herding and nipping at the heels of children or people. They may also engage in destructive behaviors like chewing or digging. Excessive barking can be a result of boredom or frustration, emphasizing the importance of providing engaging activities to keep them mentally occupied.
Similarly, Stabyhouns, like humans, may resort to problematic behaviors like digging or inappropriate chewing when they become bored. Keeping them occupied and mentally stimulated throughout the day with puzzle toys and engaging activities can help prevent the development of undesirable habits. Providing suitable outlets for their energy and curiosity can contribute to maintaining their well-being.
Training & Exercise of Stabyhoun and Border Collie
Border Collies have high exercise and mental stimulation requirements, making them unsuitable for apartment dwellers unless the owner is highly active and can provide extensive exercise. Running marathons or engaging in activities where the dog can accompany the owner is beneficial. Having a fenced-in backyard is a minimum requirement to allow the Border Collie to burn off excess energy.
In contrast, Stabyhouns require daily exercise for their mental and physical well-being, but not to the same extent as Border Collies. They typically need around an hour of exercise each day. Afterward, they are content to rest quietly. However, it’s essential to provide them with mental challenges. Stabyhouns thrive when they have a purpose in their daily lives, and activities like agility, hunting, scent training, and lure coursing can provide the necessary variety and mental stimulation for them.
Taking Care & Maintenance of Stabyhoun versus Border Collie
The Border Collie’s double coat is low-maintenance, designed to withstand long working hours in various weather conditions. The top coat comes in different lengths and textures, but both are typically self-cleaning, reducing the need for frequent baths. Brushing the Border Collie once a week, or more for longer fur, is usually sufficient. Using a slicker brush helps manage shedding, prevent matting, remove dirt, and promote healthy skin.
The Stabyhoun doesn’t require excessive grooming. Regular brushing, particularly behind the ears, helps prevent matting. Thorough brushing during shedding periods, which occur twice a year, can minimize shedding duration.
Grooming a Stabyhoun versus Border Collie
Border Collies require minimal grooming maintenance. While professional hair trimming is not necessary, regular brushing can help reduce shedding. It is important to clean their eyes and ears frequently to prevent infections. Regular flea treatments should not be overlooked. Bathing and nail trimming are also beneficial for their overall cleanliness.
On the other hand, Stabyhouns have low grooming needs. Any necessary hair clipping can be done at home, except for neutering. Neutering may result in the development of a more noticeable undercoat, requiring slightly more maintenance. However, the medium-length coat of the Stabyhoun is typically self-cleaning, allowing dirt to easily come off when the coat is dry.
Border Collies, with their long hair and double coat, are prone to heavy shedding. Keeping up with the shedding can be a significant maintenance task for owners, particularly during the fall and spring seasons when it can be particularly thick.
Similarly, Stabyhoun dogs also have a higher tendency to shed. Their hair growth cycle includes a natural phase of hair loss. The amount and frequency of shedding may vary depending on the individual dog’s health and breed.
Health Comparison between Friese Stabij and Border Collie
Border Collies, despite being generally considered a healthy breed, may be more prone to certain health issues compared to other breeds as they age and reach a longer lifespan. In contrast, the Stabyhoun is fortunate to be recognized as a relatively robust breed, despite its limited population.
Border Collies are known for their exceptional physical fitness, as they were bred for specific working purposes. They typically have an average lifespan of around 12 years. On the other hand, Stabyhouns have a relatively longer lifespan compared to other breeds, averaging around 13 to 14 years.
Diet & Nutrition
To support the active lifestyle and maintain muscle health, Border Collies should be provided with premium dog food that is rich in protein. Including foods high in Omega-3 fatty acids can also promote a shiny coat and support joint health.
Meanwhile, Stabyhouns can thrive on high-quality commercial dog food or a vet-approved homemade diet. It is important to select a diet suitable for the dog’s specific life stage (puppy, adult, or senior). It should be noted that some Stabyhouns may be prone to weight gain, so it is crucial to monitor their weight and calorie intake to prevent obesity.
Border Collies are known to have the potential to develop several health conditions. These include canine hip dysplasia, which affects the hip joint, Collie eye anomaly, a genetic eye disorder, hypothyroidism, a hormonal disorder, osteochondritis dissecans, a joint disorder, lens luxation, a displacement of the eye lens, canine idiopathic epilepsy, a neurological disorder causing seizures, progressive retinal atrophy, which leads to progressive vision loss, and patent ductus arteriosus, a heart defect.
Similarly, the Stabyhoun breed may be prone to certain health issues. These include joint dysplasia, a condition affecting the joints, patent ductus arteriosus, a heart defect, epilepsy, a neurological disorder causing seizures, type 1 Von Willebrands disease (VWB), a bleeding disorder, and cataracts, which can impair vision.
Cost of breeding a Friese Stabij and Border Collie
The cost of a Border Collie can vary depending on factors such as the breeder’s reputation, the puppy’s genetics and pedigree, location, and intended purpose (pet or show dog). Show-quality puppies generally command higher prices compared to pet-quality puppies.
On the other hand, Stabyhouns may have fewer options available as they are a rare breed with limited breeders. Pricing may be influenced by both the breed’s rarity and consumer demand. Given the scarcity of Stabyhouns, breeders may have more flexibility in setting their prices.
It is important for potential owners to conduct thorough research and find reputable breeders who prioritize the health, temperament, and well-being of their puppies. Additionally, regardless of the breed or initial cost, individuals should consider the ongoing responsibilities and expenses associated with dog ownership.
For purebred Border Collie puppies, the price typically falls within the range of $600 to $1,200 for similar show quality. It is important to conduct thorough research on breeders to ensure they meet the necessary standards.
Acquiring a Stabyhoun puppy can be challenging, with prices ranging from $1,000 to $3,200. Factors such as the breeder’s reputation, uncommon coat colors, and potential importation can affect the price. The American Stabyhoun Association has established a price range of $2,000 to $3,200.
Breeders & Centers
While purchasing a Border Collie puppy from a breeder can be expensive, adoption is another option to consider. Border Collies can be adopted from various shelters and rescue groups at a cost ranging from $200 to $400.
It’s important to note that prices may vary depending on the location and the specific rescue facility chosen. Adoption fees often cover essential procedures such as veterinary checkups and spaying or neutering. On the other hand, due to its rarity with only 6,000 individuals worldwide, finding a Stabyhoun available for adoption can be extremely challenging.
Conclusion: Which Is Better, Friese Stabij or Border Collie?
If you lead an active lifestyle and enjoy spending time outdoors, a Border Collie can be a fantastic addition to your family. They excel in sports and activities such as hiking, obedience, and agility competitions, and they thrive on physical challenges. However, it’s important to be realistic about the time and effort required to meet their exercise and mental stimulation needs. Border Collies can develop behavioral issues if their exercise requirements are not adequately fulfilled. If you have a busy schedule or prefer more relaxed activities, a Border Collie may not be the right fit for you.
On the other hand, Stabyhouns are known for their kind and sociable nature. They get along well with people, other animals, and children, and they enjoy playing with kids. Stabyhouns also appreciate having a job or purpose that engages their minds and require regular exercise. They are energetic dogs who benefit from both physical and mental challenges.
When choosing between a Border Collie and a Stabyhoun, consider your lifestyle, activity level, and ability to provide the necessary exercise and mental stimulation. Select the breed that best aligns with your preferences and capabilities, as both breeds have unique characteristics and needs.