Complete Breed Comparison for Border Collie and Pug

Border Collies are known for their exceptional intelligence and these dogs are often considered one of the most trainable breeds. They thrive on mental stimulation and require lots of exercise to keep them happy and healthy. Meanwhile, Pug have a unique charm that has won over many hearts worldwide. These small-sized dogs are known for their friendly nature and love being near their owners. Pugs are generally low-energy dogs that enjoy spending quality time with their families, whether going on leisurely walks or snuggling up on the couch.

When choosing the perfect furry companion, the debate on which to get between a Border Collie and a Pug arises. Both breeds have their own unique characteristics and charm that make them beloved pets in households around the world. So whether you’re seeking a brilliant, active working dog or a lovable, affectionate lapdog, this comparison will provide valuable insights into what qualities makes each dog breed distinct.

Characteristics Comparison between Border Collie and Pug

While both breeds have their unique charm, they also possess contrasting qualities that make them stand out.

Border Collies are known for their high intelligence and exceptional working abilities. They are often regarded as one of the most intelligent dog breeds. If you’re looking for a canine companion who is quick to learn commands and excels at various tasks or sports, such as agility or obedience trials, then a Border Collie could be an excellent choice.

Their energy levels are generally high, making them ideal pets for active individuals or families who enjoy outdoor activities.

On the other hand, Pugs bring forth a different set of qualities that appeal to many prospective pet owners. Known for their affectionate nature and friendly disposition towards humans and animals alike, they make wonderful companions for individuals seeking loyal companionship without requiring extensive exercise routines like some other breeds.

Border Collies thrive in an environment that offers mental stimulation and regular physical exercise, whereas Pugs appreciate companionship and a more relaxed lifestyle.

History of Breeds

The history of the Border Collie is as captivating as the breed itself. Originating from the border region between Scotland and England, this remarkable dog has a rich and storied past that spans centuries. Revered for their exceptional intelligence, agility, and unwavering work ethic, Border Collies have played an integral role in the lives of shepherds and farmers throughout history.

In the 18th century, these dogs were selectively bred for their unparalleled herding instincts. Their keen ability to control livestock precision and efficiency made them indispensable on farms across the border regions. Over time, they became renowned for their relentless drive, quick thinking, and natural aptitude for understanding complex commands.

As agricultural practices evolved and modernized, so did the role of Border collies. They seamlessly transitioned from working on farmlands to showcasing their incredible talents in competitive dog sports such as sheepdog trials. Their exceptional performance in these events further solidified their reputation as one of the most skilled herding breeds.

Beyond their impressive working abilities, Border Collies have also captured hearts as cherished companions and loyal family pets. Their affectionate nature combined with an innate desire to please their human counterparts has made them beloved household members around the globe.

Today, the legacy of this extraordinary breed continues to thrive. From farmyards to agility courses to family homes, Border Collies continue to exemplify a remarkable history and a promising future filled with endless possibilities.

Pugs, on the other hand, one of the most beloved dog breeds today, have a rich and fascinating history that stretches back centuries. Originally from China, these adorable and distinctive dogs have been cherished companions for generations. Their journey from ancient China to becoming a popular breed worldwide is a testament to their charm and unique characteristics.

The history of pugs can be traced back to around 400 BC when Chinese emperors highly regarded them. These regal canines were treasured as royal companions and were even given their dedicated living quarters in the imperial palaces. It is said that pugs were treated with great respect and were often guarded by soldiers to ensure their safety.

As time passed, pugs found their way to Europe through trading routes during the 16th century. They quickly gained popularity among European nobility, particularly in countries like the Netherlands and England. Queen Victoria of England was particularly fond of pugs and played an instrumental role in popularizing the breed throughout Britain.

Throughout history, pugs have captured people’s hearts from various walks of life. From royalty to artists and everyday pet lovers, these charming dogs have left an indelible mark on our affection for canines.

Appearance Comparison

Border Collies and the Pug have distinct physical characteristics that set them apart. The Border Collie is known for its athletic build and medium-sized body. With a sleek coat that can come in various colors, including black and white, red and white, or tri-color, this breed exudes elegance and agility.

On the other hand, the Pug is characterized by its compact size and distinctive facial features. With a sturdy build and a wrinkled face, it’s hard to resist their charm. Pugs have distinct physical features that set them apart from other dog breeds – they possess large round eyes giving them an endearing expression. Their short coats can come in shades such as fawn, silver fawn, apricot fawn, or black.

Breed Size

Border collies are known for their intelligence and agility. On average, they stand between 18 to 22 inches tall and weigh between 27 to 45 pounds. These medium-sized dogs are lean and athletic, making them well-suited for herding and obedience training.

On the other hand, Pugs are small-sized dogs with distinctive wrinkled faces and curly tails. They typically measure between 10 to 14 inches in height and weigh around 13 to 20 pounds. Despite their compact size, Pugs are known for their charming personalities and friendly nature.

Coats & Colors

Border Collies typically have a robust, medium-sized body with a smooth or rough double coat in various colors, including black-and-white, red-and-white, tri-colors, or merles. Their striking eyes often captivate onlookers with their intensity and expressiveness.

Personality & Temperament of Border Collie versus Pug

The Border Collie is known for its intelligence, agility, and high energy levels. This breed thrives on mental stimulation and requires plenty of exercises to stay happy. They are trainable and excel in obedience training, herding trials, and agility competitions. With their strong work ethic, Border Collies make excellent working dogs.

The Pug is a breed known for its charming and mischievous personality. Pugs are typically very friendly and sociable, making them excellent family pets. They often become quite attached to their human family members and can be quite affectionate.

They’re intelligent and can be trained, but sometimes their stubborn temperament can make them a little challenging to work with. Pugs are known for their playful, and they usually get along well with children and other pets.

While both breeds have distinct personalities and temperaments, it’s important to remember that individual dogs can vary within a breed. Factors such as socialization, training methods, and individual experiences can greatly influence a dog’s behavior.


Pugs are generally good with children, being patient and tolerant towards them. Their playful nature brings joy to kids, creating a strong bond between them. However, like any other breed, supervision is essential when young children interact with dogs to ensure safety for both parties.

Another advantage of Pugs as family pets is their adaptability to different living environments. Whether you live in a small apartment or a spacious house, these compact dogs can easily adjust to any available space. This makes them suitable for families living in urban areas or without large outdoor areas.

Pugs also have relatively low exercise requirements compared to some other breeds. While they enjoy daily walks and playtime, they don’t require extensive exercise or large yards for running around. This can be advantageous if your family has a busy schedule or limited outdoor space.

Border Collies are known to be one of the smartest dog breeds out there. Their quick learning abilities make them ideal for families who enjoy engaging with their pets through mental stimulation and training exercises.

However, it’s essential to note that this high intelligence level also requires regular mental stimulation. Border Collies can become bored or develop behavioral issues if not given enough opportunities to exercise their minds. So if you’re considering adopting this breed, be prepared to invest time providing them with plenty of mental challenges.

Border Collies are also renowned for their boundless energy and athleticism. They thrive on physical activities like long walks or runs, games of fetch or frisbee, or participating in organized dog sports like flyball or dock diving. Therefore, if you lead an active lifestyle or have children who love outdoor playtime and adventures with furry friends by their side, the Border Collie could be an excellent fit for your family dynamic.

Furthermore; while these dogs tend to be very loyal toward their families; they can sometimes be reserved around strangers until adequately introduced; making them natural watchdogs. This characteristic can be seen as an advantage for families seeking a protective and vigilant dog.


Border Collies are incredibly intelligent. This means they can quickly learn commands and tricks, making them an ideal playmate for kids who enjoy teaching their four-legged friends new things. Their quick learning abilities enable them to adapt well to different family dynamics and environments.

Furthermore, Border Collies have an innate herding instinct. While this may not seem directly related to children, it translates into their natural protective nature. They tend to be watchful of their owners and will go above and beyond to ensure their safety. This makes them excellent watchdogs for keeping an eye on your little ones.

Another reason why Border Collies make great companions for kids is their high energy levels, which align perfectly with the energy levels of most children. Whether playing fetch in the backyard or going on long walks together, these dogs will keep up with your kids’ boundless energy.

It’s worth noting that, like any other breed, proper training and socialization are crucial for a harmonious relationship between a Border Collie and children. Teaching both parties how to interact respectfully will ensure a positive experience for everyone involved.

Pugs, conversely, are known to be sociable and affectionate towards their owners, including children. They thrive on human companionship and enjoy being part of the family dynamic. Another reason why pugs are great for kids is their adaptability. These dogs are versatile creatures that easily adjust to different environments and lifestyles.

Whether you live in an apartment or have a spacious house with a backyard, pugs will happily adapt to their surroundings as long as they receive enough love, attention, and exercise.

Teaching your children about responsible pet ownership from an early age will ensure a harmonious relationship between your child and their furry friend.

Other People

Border Collies behavior towards strangers can vary from dog to dog. While some Border Collies may be naturally friendly and sociable towards strangers, others may be more reserved or cautious.

Proper socialization is crucial in determining how a Border Collie will interact with strangers. Early and ongoing socialization helps them develop positive associations with unfamiliar people, making them more likely to be accepting and friendly. Owners must expose their Border Collies to various social situations, including meeting new people in a controlled environment.

While some Border Collies may naturally be aloof or wary of strangers, genetics, past experiences, and training methods can also influence this behavior. With proper training and positive reinforcement techniques, it is possible to help your Border Collie become more comfortable and accepting of unfamiliar individuals.

It’s important to note that every dog is unique, and individual personalities can vary within the breed. Some Border Collies may exhibit a strong instinct to protect their family members or property, making them more cautious towards strangers. However, this natural protective instinct can also be channeled through training into appropriate behaviors that allow the dog to distinguish between friends and potential threats.

Whereas pugs are known for their friendly and sociable nature, making them generally good with both familiar faces and strangers alike. With their affectionate disposition and love for human interaction, pugs approach strangers with curiosity and openness.

However, as with any breed, individual personality traits may vary. It is always recommended to introduce any dog, including a pug, to new people in a controlled and calm manner to ensure positive interactions between the dog and the stranger.

Dogs & Other Animals

Border collies are known for their strong desire to work, which can often manifest as herding behavior towards other animals, including dogs. While this instinctual behavior is a natural part of their breed characteristics, it can sometimes result in challenges when introducing them to other pets.

However, with proper training and socialization from an early age, border collies can learn to coexist peacefully with other animals. The key lies in providing them ample opportunities for socialization and positive experiences with different species. Early exposure to various animals will help border collies understand appropriate behaviors and develop good manners when interacting with others.

Additionally, consistent training that focuses on obedience commands such as “leave it” or “stay” can be beneficial in managing a border collie’s herding tendencies around other pets. You can encourage a harmonious household by teaching them these commands and reinforcing positive behaviors around other animals. It is also important to note that every dog is an individual, so while the breed may have certain predispositions towards particular behaviors, each dog will have its own unique personality traits.

Pugs are known for their friendly and affectionate disposition, making them generally good companions for humans and animals. Their playful nature lets them get along well with other dogs as they enjoy socializing. However, as with any breed or individual dog’s personality, there may be exceptions where some pugs may display aggression or dislike towards certain dogs or animals.

It is crucial to gradually introduce a new pug to existing pets while closely monitoring their interactions. This will help ensure a harmonious bond between them without any unnecessary conflicts. Positive reinforcement training methods can also be implemented to encourage appropriate behavior when interacting with other animals.

Behavior Issues

One typical behavior issue in border collies is excessive energy and a strong herding instinct. Without proper energy and mental stimulation outlets, they may become restless or even engage in destructive behaviors. It is important to provide them with regular exercise and mental challenges to keep them content.

Another behavior issue that may arise in border collies is separation anxiety. These dogs form strong bonds with their owners and can become anxious when left alone for extended periods.

Border collies are highly intelligent dogs that thrive on learning and problem-solving tasks. If not given enough mental stimulation, they may find their entertainment, including chewing furniture or excessive barking. Engaging them in training sessions or dog sports such as agility or obedience can help channel their intelligence into productive activities.

It is common for Pugs to exhibit separation anxiety as these lapdogs thrive in human companionship. Leaving them for a longer period can lead to excessive barking, destructive chewing, or self-harming behaviors which can be averted by acclimating your pet to being alone at times and providing mentally stimulating toys.

Additionally, pugs are known for being stubborn at times. They have a mind and may require extra patience during training sessions. Consistency, positive reinforcement, and firm but gentle guidance are key when teaching a pug good manners and acceptable behaviors.

Training & Exercise of Border Collie versus Pug

As highly active working dogs, Border Collies thrive on mental and physical stimulation. Regular exercise is a must for this breed to prevent boredom and behavioral issues. Border Collies excel in activities such as agility training, obedience trials, and herding exercises. Their high trainability allows them to learn complex commands quickly, making them ideal candidates for advanced training programs.

On the other hand, Pugs have a more relaxed temperament compared to Border Collies. While they still require daily exercise to maintain a healthy weight and overall well-being, their exercise needs are generally lower in intensity compared to their energetic counterparts. Short walks or play sessions are usually sufficient for a Pug’s exercise routine.

In terms of training, both breeds benefit from positive reinforcement techniques such as rewards-based training methods. However, it is important to note that Border Collies may require more mental stimulation due to their higher intelligence levels. They thrive when presented with challenging tasks that engage their problem-solving abilities.

Taking Care & Maintenance of Border Collie versus Pug

Two popular breeds often come to mind are the Border Collie and the Pug. While both breeds have unique traits and charm, they also require different levels of care to ensure their health and well-being.

Taking care of a Border Collie requires an active lifestyle due to their high energy levels. They thrive on daily exercises, such as long walks or playing fetch in a spacious area. Mental stimulation is also crucial for this intelligent breed, as they excel in activities like agility training or obedience classes. Additionally, regular grooming is necessary to keep their long coats clean and free from matting.

On the other hand, caring for a Pug involves understanding their specific health needs. Due to their brachycephalic nature (short snouts), Pugs are prone to respiratory issues. Therefore, providing them with a relaxed and well-ventilated environment is important, especially during hot weather. Regular vet check-ups are essential to monitor any potential breathing problems or eye issues that may arise.

Both breeds require proper nutrition tailored to their individual needs. A balanced diet is crucial for maintaining optimal weight and overall health in Border Collies and Pugs.

Grooming Comparison

The Border Collie has a longer coat that requires regular brushing to prevent matting, especially during shedding season. On the other hand, Pugs have shorter coats that are relatively easy to maintain with regular brushing.


Shedding can vary significantly between dog breeds, and two popular breeds that showcase contrasting shedding characteristics are the Border Collie and the Pug.

The Border Collie, known for its intelligence and herding abilities, has a moderately dense double coat that requires regular grooming. While they shed year-round, their shedding increases during seasonal changes. This means that you can expect some loose hairs around your home, but with regular brushing and grooming sessions, you can minimize the impact of shedding.

In contrast, the Pug has a short and smooth coat that sheds minimally throughout the year. Their single-layered coat is relatively low-maintenance when it comes to grooming. However, it’s important to note that even though Pugs shed less than other breeds, there will still be some loose hair in their vicinity.

Health Comparison between a Border Collie and Pug

Border Collies are known for their intelligence and athleticism. However, these energetic dogs may be prone to certain health conditions that owners should be aware of. On the other hand, Pugs are characterized by their adorable wrinkled faces and friendly personalities. Although they are generally a healthy breed, they have some distinct health concerns that require attention.

A responsible owner should ensure up-to-date vaccinations, provide appropriate dental care, and monitor weight management closely. Understanding the potential health challenges and best practices for maintaining a healthy lifestyle can go a long way in promoting longevity and happiness for both Border Collies and Pugs.

Diet & Nutrition

A well-balanced diet rich in high-quality proteins, healthy fats, and carbohydrates is crucial for providing the necessary nutrients for your Border Collie’s daily activities. Additionally, incorporating vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants into their diet can help support their immune system and promote longevity.

Furthermore, ensuring access to fresh water is imperative for maintaining proper hydration. Adequate hydration supports digestion, regulates body temperature, and aids nutrient absorption.

By prioritizing the diet and nutrition of your Border Collie, you are investing in their long-term health and happiness. A nourishing diet tailored to their specific needs will provide them with the energy they need and contribute to strong bones, a shiny coat, healthy skin, and overall vitality.

While for pug, they opt for high-quality food specifically formulated for small-breed dogs. These formulas typically contain the ideal blend of vitamins, proteins, fats, carbohydrates, and minerals to meet their unique nutritional requirements.

Portion control is crucial in maintaining a healthy weight for your pug. Overfeeding may lead to obesity and other health issues. Consult with your veterinarian or refer to the feeding guidelines on the dog food packaging to check the appropriate portion size based on your pug’s age, weight, activity level, and overall health.

Establishing a consistent feeding schedule is beneficial as it helps regulate their digestion and prevents them from overeating or becoming hungry throughout the day. Dividing their daily intake into two or three smaller meals is generally recommended.

In addition to regular dog food meals, consider incorporating some healthy treats into your pug’s diet as rewards during training sessions or as occasional indulgences.

Remember that each dog is unique in terms of dietary requirements; therefore, it’s important to monitor your Border Collie’s weight regularly and adjust their food intake accordingly.

Health Issues

The Border Collie is known for its strong health. This breed generally has a longer lifespan compared to many other dog breeds. While Border Collies generally have few major health issues if bred responsibly from healthy parents, they can be prone to hereditary health conditions such as hip dysplasia or eye problems like collie eye anomaly (CEA).

On the other hand, Pugs have some distinctive health considerations due to their unique physical features. Their short muzzles can lead to breathing difficulties, known as brachycephalic syndrome.

Additionally, Pugs are prone to obesity if not properly managed through portion control and regular exercise. Potential owners should also be aware of potential eye problems in this breed, such as corneal ulcers or dry eye syndrome. It is essential for both breeds that regular veterinary check-ups are scheduled throughout their lives.

Cost of breeding Border Collie and Pug

The price range for purchasing a Pug typically falls between $300 and $500, while acquiring a Border Collie can range from $600 to $800. These figures can vary depending on factors such as location, breeder reputation, and the specific characteristics of the individual dog.


The Pug breed typically has a smaller litter size than the Border Collie. On average, Pugs tend to produce 2 to 4 puppies per litter. This smaller litter size is often attributed to their unique physical characteristics and body structure.

In contrast, Border Collies are known for having a larger litter. They generally produce between 6 to 9 puppies per litter. This higher number of puppies can be attributed to their history as working dogs and their ability to handle physically demanding tasks.

It is important to note that these numbers are just averages, and individual dogs may have slightly different outcomes when it comes to the size of their litter. Factors such as breeding practices and proper care during pregnancy can also influence the final number of puppies a dog may have.

Breeders & Centers

Finding a responsible breeder is essential to ensure you get a healthy and well-socialized puppy. A reputable breeder will prioritize the overall health of their dogs, conducting necessary health screenings, vaccinations, and genetic testing to prevent hereditary diseases.

Centers dedicated to Border Collies and Pugs often serve as rescue organizations or shelters that provide temporary care for abandoned or surrendered dogs. These centers offer a haven for these breeds, providing medical attention, rehabilitation if needed, and ultimately finding them loving forever homes.

When searching for breeders or centers, it is important to look for those who follow ethical breeding practices and prioritize the welfare of their animals. They should provide proper socialization opportunities for the puppies or dogs under their care and be knowledgeable about breed-specific traits, temperaments, and potential health issues.

Additionally, reputable breeders will usually be open about answering any questions you may have about the breed’s history and the lineage of their dogs, as well as providing necessary documentation such as health records and registration papers.

Conclusion: Which Is Better, Border Collie or Pug?

Ultimately, choosing between a Border Collie and a Pug comes down to your preferences and lifestyle factors. The Border Collie may be the better choice if you’re looking for an intelligent working dog who thrives in an active environment.

However, the Pug might be the perfect fit if you’re seeking a loving and low-maintenance companion. When deciding, consider factors such as exercise requirements, grooming needs, and potential health issues. Whichever breed you choose, Border Collies and Pugs are known for their loyalty and ability to bring joy to their families.

Leave a Comment