Border Collie vs Great Pyrenees Comparison

The Border Collie is an English and Scottish working and herding dog breed that originated in the lowland and border countries. It is known for its high energy, intelligence, and obedience. The breed is characterized by a strong desire to work, an eagerness to please, alertness, and teamwork.

Their unique combination of power, speed, and agility makes them well-suited for herding sheep or cattle. They are also used as therapy dogs due to their friendly and loyal nature. This breed has a long history of being used as working dogs in rural areas of the United Kingdom.

Border Collies are highly trainable due to their intelligence level. They can learn new tricks quickly with consistent training. They make excellent companions for active families that can provide plenty of exercise and stimulation.

Although their high levels of activity mean they aren’t the best choice for first-time dog owners, once trained they make devoted companions and loving members of the family.

Great Pyrenees, on the other hand, are a large and strong dog breed with roots in the Pyrenees Mountains of France and Spain. It is an ancient breed with a long history as a working dog, guarding flocks of sheep for centuries. This majestic breed has been praised for its gentle nature, intelligence, and loyalty.

The Great Pyrenees is an accomplished guard dog, loyal companion, and loving family member! They are strong-willed yet patient and make wonderful guardians for families with children. They can become devoted members of any family with proper training, socialization, and love.

Dog breed Border Collie Great Pyrenees
Country of Origin Scotland Europe
Origin year 1700 1800
Breed type Pure breed Pure breed
Lifespan 12-15 years 10-12 years
Personality & Temperament energetic, protective, alert, intelligent, loyal, responsive affectionate, loyal, confident, gentle, adventurous, fearless
Coat Smooth or rough double coat Double dense coat
Height 18-22 inches 25-32 inches
Weight 27 to 45 pounds 80 to 160 pounds
Family friendly Yes Yes
Kids friendly Yes Yes
Stranger friendly Yes No

Comparing Key Characteristics of Border Collie and Great Pyrenees

Border Collies and Great Pyrenees are two very popular breeds of dogs that are widely recognized for their intelligence, friendly attitude, and loyalty. Although these two breeds have some similarities in terms of their looks, temperament, and behavior, distinct features set them apart from each other.

Breed History of Border Collie and Great Pyrenees

Border Collies have been around since the 1700s in regions of England and Scotland. Farmers used them to herd their sheep, being known for their agility and stamina.

While the breed’s exact origin is unknown, some breed historians believe there might be a spaniel somewhere in the mix. In the 19th century, Border Collies were used to herd animals such as cattle and sheep, as well as work in fields such as search and rescue, drug detection, police work, and more. They have also been trained to compete in sheepdog trials and are often seen participating in agility competitions.

Their intelligence and versatility have made them popular in a variety of roles and have proven their worth throughout history. One of their most important roles may be helping people with disabilities live better lives. With specialized training for blind or visually impaired people, these remarkable animals provide guidance and companionship that can be invaluable in times of need.

Today, Border Collies are popular companion dogs that are loyal and quick-learning, excelling at tasks given to them.

The Great Pyrenees, or Pyrenean Mountain Dog, on the other hand is an ancient breed of working dog that dates back to 1800 to 1000 BC. Their size and power allowed them to be used for a variety of tasks like herding animals, keeping flocks safe from predators and even assisting in rescue operations.

It was originated from the Pyrenees Mountains. It was bred to be a guard dog for herds of sheep and protect them from predators such as wolves and bears. This breed has an interesting and long history spanning centuries, which makes it really intriguing.

Historical evidence shows that Great Pyrenees were used to pull carts during World War I, transporting smuggled goods from France to Spain. Over time, the Great Pyrenees has become an iconic symbol of loyalty, bravery, and strength.

The Great Pyrenees have been admired for their loyalty and protective nature throughout their history. They are well-known due to their friendly temperaments, affectionate personalities, gentle nature, and ability to form strong bonds with their owners.

Appearance of Border Collie and Great Pyrenees

The Great Pyrenees and the Border Collie have a unique look, with distinct body shapes and coat colors. The Great Pyrenees is larger than the Border Collie, with a longer and thicker fur coat. Its bulky size is in contrast to the slim physique of the Border Collie, which has an athletic build with short fur.

Both dogs also have distinctive facial features, including almond-shaped eyes and erect ears that give them a lively expression. While both breeds have different appearances, they share many traits, such as loyalty, intelligence, and an eagerness to please their owners.

Breed Size

Border Collie is a medium-sized herding dog with a slender physique, pointed ears, and a fierce expression. Adult Border Collies are typically between 18 and 22 inches tall at the shoulder and weigh between 27 and 45 pounds. However, depending on their pedigree, some canines may be larger or smaller than this range.

The Great Pyrenees, on the other hand is a large breed of dog known for its thick white coat and impressive size. Adult Great Pyrenees typically measure 25-32 inches tall at the shoulder and weigh between 85-160 pounds. They have a muscular body with a broad chest, short legs, long ears, and a thick tail that curves over its back.

Coats & Colors

Border collies are a breed of dog with a variety of different coat types. Their coats can range from short and dense to long and feathered. Most border collie coats are straight, but some may have a wavy texture. The length of their coat can vary from short to moderately long, depending on the individual animal.

Border collies also come in a variety of beautiful colors. While the most common color is black and white, there are many more unique shades to choose from. From classic black and tan to rarer shades like red, sable, brindle, and lilac, there is sure to be a border collie color that suits you perfectly. Other popular border collie colors include gold, seal, slate, tricolor, and more! No matter your border collie’s color, it will always be an intelligent and loyal companion.

The Great Pyrenees is a breed well-known for its long and thick coat that consists of two layers, an inner layer full of dense fur and an outer layer with white in color. In the colder climates of the mountainous regions, their fur has adapted to provide insulation from the cold temperatures. The thick coat they have makes them equipped to survive and thrive in such conditions.

Personality & Temperament of Border Collie vs. Great Pyrenees

Personality and temperament are two of the most important elements when it comes to understanding your dog. Knowing these can help you better understand their behavior, which could prevent a lot of potential problems down the line.

The personality and temperament of dogs varies with their breeds and moreso, individually. Each type has its own characteristics that can help you determine how your dog may act in different situations. Other factors like age and gender can influence a dog’s personality and temperament.

Border Collies and the Great Pyrenees have distinct personalities and temperaments that can affect how they interact with humans, animals, and their environment.

The Border Collie is a highly intelligent, energetic, and loyal dog breed that has been around for centuries. They are recognized for their alertness and protective temperament, making them the ideal companion for anybody looking for a loyal and attentive pet.

Although border collies are well-known for their herding abilities, they also possess many other qualities that make them an ideal pet. They are very responsive to training and eager to please their owners, making them easy to train and teach commands. Their intelligence also makes them particularly good at learning new behavior quickly. Additionally, these dogs are loyal to their families and will do anything to protect them from harm.

However, owning a border collie requires consistency in daily routine. They don’t like unexpected changes or a noisy house environment. Their owners must provide the right level of exercise on a regular basis. Otherwise, the dog may become bored or frustrated, which can lead to destructive behaviors such as chewing furniture or barking excessively.

While Great Pyrenees is a large, confident, and affectionate dog breed, they are known for their patient and gentle personalities but also have a strong will and fearless nature when needed. This breed is very sensitive to their owner’s feelings, making them both easy to train but also need strong leadership.

The Great Pyrenees have an adventurous spirit that leads to a high potential for wanderlust. This can be a challenge for owners who do not keep the dog on a leash or in an enclosed area. The breed also has an impulse to chase and catch small animals like cats, birds, and other small prey, which should be discouraged while training them.

Overall the Great Pyrenees can make great family pets with the right amount of socialization and training. With their loyal personalities as well as their confident demeanor, they are sure to be a wonderful addition to your home!

border collie and great pyrenees dog breed

Comparing Family Interactions

A Border Collie is an ideal family dog for the active family. These dogs need a lot of activity and stimulation, so families that are busy and enjoy outdoor activities will find that their Border Collie fits into their lifestyle perfectly. While these dogs are friendly and loyal, they require great deal of attention from their owners to keep healthy and happy. A Border Collie may be the ideal pet for individuals looking for a friendly companion who will keep them occupied.

On the other hand, a Great Pyrenees is known to be gentle and loyal, but proper training and socialization are required in order for them to thrive in a family environment. With the right amount of care and attention from their owners, they can be wonderful companions who are fine with families of all ages and sizes.

Kids with Border Collie vs Great Pyrenees

Border collies can be good for children, but ensuring that the animal is properly trained and supervised is important. While border collies are generally good with children of all ages, they may be better with older kids who won’t chase after them or try to grab their fur. With proper supervision and training, a border collie can make a great companion for a family with kids.

Great Pyrenees are known to be gentle, affectionate, and loving around children. They enjoy the company of children and can be a great companion for them. However, it is important to note that they need supervision if they are not used to being around young ones.

If left unsupervised, they may become agitated or overwhelmed by the child’s energy. It is also important to train Great Pyrenees properly so that they understand how to behave around children and know their limits when playing with them. With proper training and supervision, Great Pyrenees can make great companions for children.

Other People

Border collies might be reserved around strangers, but they will warm up fast with time and care. Socializing your border collie from the very start is important to ensure he is comfortable around strangers.

This includes exposing kids to new people, places, and settings in a secure and supervised manner so that they learn to trust unfamiliar faces. A border collie can become sociable with strangers as well as other family members and pets with the correct socialization practices.

Great Pyrenees dogs are known for being loyal to the people they know and trust. But when it comes to strangers, they can be wary. This can make them difficult to introduce to new people or environments, so understanding their behavior is key in order to make sure they are comfortable and safe in those situations.

With proper socialization, Great Pyrenees can learn how to interact with strangers appropriately and become more accepting of them. Obedience training is also important for teaching the dog what behaviors are acceptable around people who are unfamiliar or uncomfortable. With the right guidance and patience, a Great Pyrenees can develop into a friendly companion who is comfortable with familiar faces and strangers.

Dogs & Other Animals

Border collies are considered to be great with other animals. These dogs can get along well with other pets, provided they are introduced properly and given enough space to adjust.

They are also said to have a high level of obedience, making them easier to train than some other breeds. A Border Collie, with the right kind of training and socialization, can be a wonderful comapanion for another animals.

When properly raised and socialized, the Great Pyrenees can get along with other animals. While they normally get along with all animals, they can be rough with dogs of the same sex.

It is, therefore, critical to use caution while introducing them to new canine companions. Because of their height and power, good socialization and training are essential to ensuring a happy connection between your Great Pyrenees and other animals.

Behaviour Issues

Border Collie and Great Pyrenees have unique behavior issues that can arise depending on how they are raised and trained. While they may share some similarities in terms of their characteristics, there are a few differences in how they act.

Border collies are popular because of their intelligence, and herding abilities. These characteristics are wonderful to have in a dog, but they can lead to undesirable behaviors if the dog is not appropriately trained. These behaviors include herding, biting children or adults’ heels, chewing, digging, barking excessively, and more.

These behavioral difficulties can be highly frustrating for owners who don’t know how to control them. Border collies require proper socialization, consistent mental stimulation, and training to avoid developing these disruptive and harmful tendencies. Border collies can be trained to regulate their energy levels while becoming obedient and loving companions with the appropriate direction.

On the other hand, Great Pyrenees can sometimes be stubborn and uncooperative when it comes to training. They may even ignore their masters in favor of resting or performing activities they want instead. This behavior can make training the breed difficult, and owners may need to employ special techniques to get the most out of their pets.

Training & Exercise of Border Collie vs Great Pyrenees

Training and exercise are essential for both Border Collies and Great Pyrenees to keep them healthy and happy. Training is necessary for both breeds to understand their roles in the family, stay calm in public settings, and have a good relationship with other animals.

Exercise is also essential for these breeds as it helps them stay physically active and reduces stress. These breeds may become unruly, destructive, and even aggressive without proper training.

Border Collies needs a lot of exercises and mental stimulation as they are extremely active dogs that require a great deal of stimulation to stay happy and healthy. They should be taken out for long walks regularly or given plenty of space to run around in an enclosed area. Additionally, they benefit from agility training or herding activities to keep them mentally stimulated.

Great Pyrenees require moderate exercises like regular walks and outdoor activities like weight pulling. Weight pulling is one of the most effective exercise methods for the Great Pyrenees because it allows them to build their general stamina and strength.

While Border Collies are very easy to train because of their intelligence, Great Pyrenees require more patience and dedication as they are known to be more stubborn than other breeds. Both breeds need regular exercise and training, but the way in which owners should approach each breed is entirely different.

Taking Care & Maintenance of Border Collie vs Great Pyrenees

Border Collies require regular care and maintenance to keep them healthy. Taking good care of a Border Collie requires a commitment to providing the best nutrition, exercise, grooming, health checkups, and training. If you want your dog to have a long and healthy life, you need to know the essentials of care and maintenance to keep it happy and healthy.

Great Pyrenees need a moderate amount of physical activity, typically around 30 minutes to an hour daily, along with 4-6 cups of food twice daily. They also should receive baths once every few months and have their ears cleaned weekly. Teeth brushing should be done 2-3 times a week as well to keep them healthy.

Grooming Comparison

Grooming is an important factor of keeping your dog healthy and happy. Not only does it keep them clean and free of mats, but it also helps with their overall well-being.

Regular grooming helps to prevent skin conditions, keep their coat in good condition and help detect any potential health issues. Furthermore, grooming can give your dog increased confidence and self-esteem.

Grooming requirements for both Border Collies and Great Pyrenees are generally the same. To maintain their coat health, it is necessary to brush them regularly.

For the Border Collie, this should be done at least once every few weeks to reduce shedding and keep its coat healthy. On the other hand, the Great Pyrenees’ thick double coats should be brushed once a week or more to prevent matting and tangling. Both breeds also require occasional baths and nail trimming for hygiene purposes.


Both Border Collie and Great Pyrenees have seasonal shedding patterns. This means they’ll both shed more during certain times of the year, usually during spring and fall. However, their shedding habits are different.

Border Collie shed profusely and continually throughout the year. On the other hand, the Great Pyrenees is considered to be a moderate-shedding breed that loses more fur during their seasonal shedding season in spring and winter.

Health of Border Collie vs Great Pyrenees

The Border Collie is a healthy dog breed, but you need to be aware that some health issues can arise. This breed has a predisposition to certain health conditions such as hip dysplasia, hypothyroidism, and epilepsy.

It is best for anyone considering getting a Border Collie to research the health history of the parents and siblings. Regular veterinary checkups can go a long way in maintaining your pet’s optimal health. Regular exercise and proper nutrition are also key components to keeping your Border Collie healthy and happy.

Great Pyrenees are strong and healthy breeds too. However, they are prone to specific health issues such as elbow and hip dysplasia, eye diseases, luxating patellas, and neurological and immune-mediated disorders.

Pet owners must be aware of these health conditions in order to discover them early and avoid any long-term consequences. In addition, regular vet visits are required to keep your pup healthy.

Life Span Comparison

The life expectancy of border collies is estimated to be between 12 to 15 years when they are properly cared for. This breed has a longer life span than other breeds due to its active lifestyle and high level of fitness.

In addition, they have strong immune systems that help them resist common ailments such as hip dysplasia and arthritis. Border collies also benefit from regular exercise and early socialization, which help them live long and healthy lives.

While the life span of a Great Pyrenees dog is between 10 to 12 years on average, they can live longer with proper care and nutrition. Their life expectancy depends on various factors such as genetics, diet, and environment.

Taking your pup to regular veterinary visits is important since early detection and treatment of any medical conditions can help increase their longevity. Additionally, providing them with a healthy diet and plenty of exercise will ensure that your Great Pyrenees live longer than the average lifespan.

Diet & Nutrition

It is well known that proper diet and nutrition are essential for dogs’ health. Not only does the right balance of nutrients keep your pup in peak condition, but it also helps prevent certain illnesses and diseases. A healthy diet for your dog can help reduce the risk of obesity, diabetes, skin problems, digestive issues, and more.

Additionally, a balanced diet and exercise can help to maintain their energy levels and keep them mentally sharp. Proper diet and nutrition also goes a long way in keeping them fit and active throughout their lifetime.

Border collies are among the most active dog breeds, so they require a balanced diet to ensure they always look and feel their best. A border collie’s diet should include raw meat, rice, veggies, and fresh water.

Occasionally adding raw meat into the dog’s diet will help keep the skin healthy and free of rashes and other issues. In addition, the dog should be fed balanced meals on a regular basis, which should consist of rice, vegetables, and other healthy foods. Border collies can live long and productive lives if they are fed properly.

A Great Pyrenees requires special attention when it comes to diet and nutrition. They have a thick white coat of fur, so they need a diet rich in omega 3 and omega 6 fatty acids to keep their coat looking luxurious. They should be fed smaller meals throughout the day as opposed to two large meals, as this can cause digestive issues.

The best food options for Great Pyrenees include raw meat, cooked chicken, vegetables, and brown rice. Raw meat is an important source of protein for these dogs, while cooked chicken provides essential vitamins and minerals.

Vegetables are also packed with beneficial nutrients for your pup, while brown rice provides a slow-burning source of energy. The combination of these ingredients will help keep your Great Pyrenees happy and healthy!

Health Issues

Border collies breed is prone to a variety of health issues. Common health problems in border collies include bacterial and viral infections, obesity, hip dysplasia, epilepsy, hypothyroidism, separation anxiety, and more.

These health issues should be monitored closely in order to keep the border collie in the best condition possible. Fortunately, these issues can be managed with proper nutrition and exercise regimens as well as regular veterinary checkups.

Great Pyrenees can be prone to certain hereditary diseases, such as hip and elbow dysplasia, eye disorders, cancer and neurological and immune-mediated conditions. These ailments may impact the canine’s quality of life and should be taken into account when considering adopting this breed.

You need to be aware of these health concerns to ensure your pet’s best care. You should also make sure to consult with your vet regularly to monitor the condition of your pet.

Cost of Border Collie vs Great Pyrenees

A good quality Border Collie puppy can cost anywhere between $800 and $3,500 depending on the breeder’s reputation. If you are looking to get one of these dogs as a pet, then it is important to be aware of the cost involved in bringing one into your family.

The price range for a reputable border collie breeder is between $800 and $1,500, while getting a top-quality puppy could cost you as much as $3,500 or more. When choosing a breeder, it is important to do your research and make sure that they have good reviews from previous customers.

It is also vital to remember that raising these puppies can be quite expensive in terms of food costs and vet bills, so make sure to consider this factor into your budget before taking the plunge!

Great Pyrenees price typically varies from breeder to breeder, depending on the bloodline, registration documents, and medical screenings that come with the dog. However, even with this variability in cost, there are other factors to consider when looking for a Great Pyrenees.

While some breeders offer puppies for sale at lower prices, most reputable breeders will charge higher rates for pups with better-quality bloodlines and registration papers. Medical screenings are also important to assess a pup’s health and its parents’ history. All of these factors together should be taken into account when calculating the cost of a Great Pyrenees puppy.

Great Pyrenees puppies can cost anywhere from $1,000 to $2,500 from reputable breeders. The price tag is $6,000 if you’re looking for top quality from a champion pedigree and exceptional genes. Great Pyrenees are popular pets, and luckily there are many reliable breeders out there who can supply you with a healthy, well-trained dog.


The number of puppies a Border Collie can have generally falls between 4-8. This is influenced by various factors, such as the age and health of the mother dog as well as if this is her first or subsequent litter.

While the Great Pyrenees can give birth to litters of between 6 and 12 puppies, making them a better choice for those looking for a big family. But before you make the decision to get a Great Pyrenees puppy, it’s important to understand what goes into caring for such an animal. Learn about how many puppies Great Pyrenees can have, how often they give birth, and what kind of care they need to stay healthy and happy.

Breeders & Centers

Breeders and Centers play a vital role in producing healthy, happy, and obedient animals. Breeding centers and breeders provide animals the security and comfort to be at their best. They ensure that animals get the right food, exercise, medical help, grooming care, and socialization with other animals.

Moreover, breeders are experts in selecting the right combination of traits for a particular breed which helps to produce healthy purebreds with desirable characteristics. Furthermore, centers provide additional services such as training classes for owners so that they can better understand their animal’s needs.

Many breeders and centers specialize in these two breeds, offering a variety of services to potential owners. Whether you’re looking for a puppy, an adult dog, or even just advice on how to care for your pet, there is sure to be a breeder or center out there for you.

Conclusion: Which Is Better, Border Collie or Great Pyrenees?

When it comes to choosing between a Border Collie or a Great Pyrenees, there really is no right or wrong answer. Both breeds have their unique characteristics and personalities that may appeal to different people.

In the end, it will always comes down to your individual preferences and lifestyle when deciding which is better for you. So, in conclusion, the best dog breed for you will be the one that best suits your needs and brings out the most joy in your life!

Leave a Comment